Progress Report

Progress Report

Why Van Hollen’s challenge for Democratic leader matters — win or lose

Also: Ohio Republicans are cool with child marriage?

Jordan Zakarin's avatar
Jordan Zakarin
Nov 21, 2026

Welcome to a Saturday edition of Progress Report.

Even though we’re headed toward Thanksgiving and few governments are in session, there’s some big national political news to discuss and important legislation moving (or not moving) in state capitals, so let’s get to it.

I’ve taken down the paywall, stopped normal billing, and made all Progress Report content — including new articles like this one and the new Election Hub site — free while I recover from open-heart surgery.

You’re invited support this work via donations to the newsletter’s GoFundMe, and every donation is very appreciated.

Donate to Progress Report!

Why Chris Van Hollen’s challenge for Democratic leader matters — win or lose

Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen’s challenge to be the next majority leader has gotten more realistic over the past few days, as supposed backers of presumed leader Chuck Schumer have stayed mum and moderates like Sen. Elissa Slotkin have thrown their support behind the insurgent. I get the sense that Schumer’s support is more default than true dedication, and considering how he’s almost certainly going to either retired or be retired come 2028, I could see the consensus around his leadership that he tried to manufacture falling apart pretty quickly.

If Schumer does wind up eking out the win, though, it’ll only further underscore why Van Hollen’s challenge has been so important.

For all the heroism of the activists and grassroots candidates who flipped seats up and down the ballot, in some of the most inhospitable political climates imaginable, the national Democratic Party is still dominated by cautious, donor-driven centrists whose idea of progress is giving the status quo a small cost of living allowance.

You could get the bends from the speed at which senior party members lowered expectations from this new 56-vote majority, at how quickly they disregarded the direct orders of voters nationwide. Just a few examples:

1. Last night, 15 Democrats joined with Republicans to pass a permitting bill that functions as a grab bag of gifts to fossil fuel companies, data centers, and developers while taking away local control from communities that vociferously rejected the parasitic capitalism enabled by the bill.

They didn’t even try to do it on the down low; Sen. Jeff Merkley’s attempt to kill the legislation garnered very public criticism from several fellow Democrats. It’s odd to be that passionate about passing a Republican priority bill when they’re a few months away from taking power with an overwhelming majority, which would allow them to pass a much better version, without all the unpopular corporate giveaways and data center assists.

2. I bring up the size of the majority, the biggest since 2009, because it still won’t be enough to pass most major legislation without killing the filibuster… which some Democrats are already saying they want to preserve going forward. Mark Warner has explicitly backed keeping the progress-killing Senate rule in place, affirming Chuck Schumer’s long-held institutionalist preference.

Van Hollen, on the other hand, has rightly called the filibuster anti-democratic and suggested that the caucus should reform or abolish it, echoing the sentiments of popular newcomers like Sen-elect James Talarico. With Trump still in office, they were never going to pass anything like Medicare for All, but with the ability to put popular reforms to a vote, they’d have the leverage over Republicans who wouldn’t otherwise have to negotiate. Being led by a guy who is eager to surrender power is self-defeating and will further limit what’s possible for a caucus that has little credit in the bank with voters.

3. On the subject of preemptive surrender, a number of veteran — and in some cases, departing — Democratic senators have already signaled that they will vote for a government budget bill even if it means continuing to fund the war in Iran. I’m well aware that there is backlash for inconveniences like crowded airports and delayed flights, especially during the holidays, but the public is far more pissed off about the illegal war that continues to jack up prices, keep families apart, and waste American tax dollars.

The war played a major role in powering Democrats to their nine-seat flip this month, and I can’t think of anything more stupid or immoral than voting to continue it before heading off for Christmas. Van Hollen has once again rightly said that the administration should not get another dime for their disaster in the Persian Gulf, while Schumer actually dared Trump to declare war in 2025.

Americans didn’t vote for Democrats so much as they vehemently rejected Donald Trump and his Republican lackies. The party has a two year tryout, a short window to lift its sagging approval ratings and reputation for meekness and collaboration.

As it so happens, there is nobody more unpopular than Chuck Schumer, so it would be absolute suicide to simply give him ultimate power over the Democratic agenda. That Van Hollen is running and galvanizing the base should serve as a reminder to DC Democrats that this is not team sports and voters will not simply rejoice at the party’s victories and take whatever crumbs it decides to toss in between giving gigantic handouts to the military industrial complex, Big Tech, and Wall Street.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Progress Report.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 Jordan Zakarin · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.